Arizona’s law raises many questions (July 15)
Friday, July 16, 2010By Chuck Doud
The Madera Tribune
It will be interesting, at the end of this month, to see what happens when the state of Arizona begins enforcement of its highly-discussed immigration law. Will the jails suddenly fill with illegals? Will federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents suddenly be overwhelmed with prisoners to be sent home?
If the answer to those questions is yes, it also will be interesting to see what happens to Arizona’s agriculture, hospitality and service economies. While nobody really knows how many illegals are employed as crop harvesters and hotel employees, if the supply of people for those jobs is suddenly reduced, hotels and farmers may have to raise wages.
When construction begins again in earnest, will wages for construction laborers have to be raised because of a shortage of workers?
Will people who used to enjoy having their yards done at reasonable rates by illegal gardeners suddenly find themselves out tending their own yards in 100-degree heat, or having to pay much more to gardeners because of labor shortages?
Will restaurant owners have to pay more for cooks, dishwashers, table servers and bus people?
Arizonans are extremely frustrated by having to pay the costs of illegal immigration. They want their border with Mexico defended. They don’t like the additional expenses of supporting those illegals who can’t find jobs, or who get sick, or who want to put their kids in schools. You can’t blame them for their frustration. You can’t blame them for their sense of outrage at being infringed upon by the uninvited.
But it will be interesting to see whether many Arizonans who have profited from the labor of illegals might regret it if the law works, and results in a substantial reduction in that state’s human capital.
Should that happen, the law could turn out to have unintended consequences that many might regret.


